• Interior
  • Sandwich with meatballs, fries on the side
  • Exterior, main entrance
  • Pizza closeup

Pizza Made
Your Way

About us

How you doin’! Papa Luigi’s has been a Cudahy landmark for close to four decades. Since 1982, Sal and his family have grown to be one of Milwaukee’s top Italian restaurants by his commitment to quality, service, and family atmosphere. We have been nominated by Shepard Express Best of Milwaukee in the categories family friendly restaurant, Italian restaurant, thin and crispy crust pizza, and best fish fry. You will be guaranteed to find value in what you order from the generous portions we offer to the wide variety of items to choose from.

Ciao ci Vediamo dopo