Our Dine in Menu
AppetizersPizzaItalian DinnersSeafood SpecialtiesSandwichesAmerican DinnersFresh From Our GardenSides
Appetizers
Garlic Bread
5.00
With Papa’s Signature Marinara Sauce
Garlic Bread with Cheese
7.00
Served with Papa’s Signature Marinara Sauce
Mama Maria’s Buttery Garlic Bread
8.00
Our Homemade Bread smothered with 100% Butter and baked to perfection
Pizza Bread
9.00
Open-Faced Italian Bread with Mozzarella Cheese, Papa’s Signature Marinara Sauce, and One Topping of your choice. Additional Toppings 1.00 Extra
Mozzarella Sticks
8.00
Served with Papa’s Signature Marinara Sauce
Breaded Mushrooms
9.00
Breaded Cauliflower
9.00
Jalapeño Poppers
9.00
With Cream Cheese
Buffalo Wings
12.00
Our Original lightly spiced, lightly coated & Sauce free Jumbo Chicken Wings
Breaded Calamari
14.00
BESTA AT FESTA ITALIANA! Hand cut, Fresh, Tender Calamari lightly coated and deep fried until golden brown
Sicilian Eggplant
8.00/Half order
13.00/Full
VOTED #1 IN SOUTHEASTERN WISCONSIN! Our Fresh cut, hand made deep-fried Eggplant served with Lemon Wedges and Papa’s Signature marinara sauce
Basket of Fries
5.00/+
Crinkled Cut $5.00 | Beer Battered $6.00 | Wedges $6.00
Chicken Platter Combo
18.00
Includes Original Buffalo Wings, Chicken Tenders, and Cheese Bread. Served with Ranch and Papa’s Signature Marinara Sauce
Mac-N-Cheese Bites
9.00
Pockets of Creamy Macaroni and Cheese, battered and fried to a golden brown
Onion Rings
9.00
Eggplant Combo
13.00
A classic combination of our Fresh cut, hand made, deep-fried Famous Eggplant, paired with our Cheesy Garlic Bread served with Papa’s Signature Marinara Sauce
Chicken Tenders
10.50
Bosco Sticks
9.00
Toasted Bruschetta
9.00
A wonderful blend of fresh diced tomato, red onion, garlic, basil, and Italian seasonings, toasted together on Italian bread with melted mozzarella cheese and sprinkled with parmesan cheese
Papa’s Combo
17.00
SAL’S FAVORITE! Breaded Mushrooms, Breaded Cauliflower, Mozzarella Sticks and Jalapeno Poppers. Served with Ranch and Papa’s Signature Marinara Sauce
Cheesecurds
10.00
Wisconsin sourced white cheddar curds lightly breaded and fried
Bone-In Papa’s Famous Jumbo Buffalo Wings
10.00/+
Jumbo Wings cooked to perfection served plain or tossed in your choice of sauce ~(8) - $10.00 | (12) - $15.00 | (16) - $20.00 | (24) - $28.00 * Sauces: Thai Chili, Spicy BBQ, BBQ, Medium, Hot, Sweet Garlic Teriyaki
Boneless Papa’s Famous Jumbo Buffalo Wings
11.50
10-12 tender chunks of All White Breast Meat breaded, cooked to perfection, and tossed in your choice of Sauce. * Sauces: Thai Chili, Spicy BBQ, BBQ, Medium, Hot, Sweet Garlic Teriyaki
Cheese
8” - 10.50 • 12” - 12.60 • 14” - 13.75 • 16” - 14.75
Hand Tossed Crust
8” - 1.00 • 12” - 1.25 • 14” - 1.50 • 16” - 1.75
Thick Crust
8” - 1.25 • 12” - 1.50 • 14” - 2.00 • 16” - 2.50
Topping Price (each)
8” - 1.00 • 12” - 1.25 • 14” - 1.75 • 16” - 1.95
Extra Sauce
8” - 1.00 • 12” - 1.25 • 14” - 1.50 • 16” - 1.75
Extra Cheese
8” - 1.30 • 12” - 1.60 • 14” - 1.85 • 16” - 2.25
Gluten-Free Cheese Pizza
10” - 11.45
Toppings
Sausage, Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Black Olives, Onions, Green Peppers, Tomatoes, Broccoli, Jalapenos, Green Olives, Canadian Bacon, Pineapple, Pepperoncini, Anchovies, Bacon, Ground Beef, Shrimp, Chicken, Spinach
Papa’s Original Thin-n-Crispy Pizza
10” Cauliflower Crust (GF)
15.75
Topping Price (each) $1.50 / Extra Sauce $1.25 / Extra Cheese $2.00
Cheese
12.00/8"
15.75/12"
17.00/14"
18.00/16"
Add: Hand Tossed Crust $1 for 8", $1.25 for 12", $1.50 for 14", $1.75 for 16" / Thick Crust $1.25 for 8", $1.50 for 12", $2 for 14", $2.50 for 16" / Topping Price (each) $1 for 8", $1.50 for 12", $2.00 for 14", $2.25 for 16" / Extra Sauce $1 for 8", $1.25 for 12", $1.50 for 14", $1.75 for 16" / Extra Cheese $1.30 for 8", $2.00 for 12", $2.25 for 14", $2.75 for 16"
TOPPINGS:
Sausage, Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Black Olives, Onions, Green Peppers, Tomatoes, Broccoli, Jalapenos, Green
Olives, Canadian Bacon, Pineapple, Pepperoncini, Anchovies, Bacon, Ground Beef, Shrimp, Chicken, Spinach
Specialty Pizza
Papa’s Veggie Pizza
13.25/+
Cheese, Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers and Black Olives | 8” - 13.25 • 10”gf - 20.00 • 12” - 20.00 • 14” - 22.50 • 16” - 24.00
Papa’s Special
13.25/+
Cheese, Sausage, Mushrooms and Onions | 8” - 13.25 • 10”gf - 20.00 • 12” - 20.00 • 14” - 22.50 • 16” - 24.00
Papa’s Deluxe
16.10/+
Cheese, Sausage, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Pepperoni, Black Olives and Onions | 8”-16.10 • 10” GF - 25.00 • 10" Cauliflower GF - 25.00 • 12”- 25.00 • 14”- 27.00 • 16”- 29.00
Chicken Alfredo Pizza
16.10/+
Alfredo Sauce, Mozzarella Cheese and tender chunks of Chicken Breast | 8”-16.10 • 10” GF - 25.00 • 10" Cauliflower GF - 25.00 • 12”- 25.00 • 14”- 27.00 • 16”- 29.00
Hawaiian Pizza
16.10/+
Papa’s Famous Pizza Sauce topped with Mozzarella Cheese, Fresh Pineapple and Canadian Bacon | 8”-16.10 • 10” GF - 25.00 • 10" Cauliflower GF - 25.00 • 12”- 25.00 • 14”- 27.00 • 16”- 29.00
BLT
16.10/+
Mozzarella Cheese, Bacon, Crisp lettuce, Tomato and Mayo Drizzle | 8”-16.10 • 10” GF - 25.00 • 10" Cauliflower GF - 25.00 • 12”- 25.00 • 14”- 27.00 • 16”- 29.00
Bigga Macka
16.10/+
1000 Island Dressing, Ground Beef, Lettuce, Diced Pickles, Diced Onions with a blend of American and Mozzarella Cheese | 8”-16.10 • 10” GF - 25.00 • 10" Cauliflower GF - 25.00 • 12”- 25.00 • 14”- 27.00 • 16”- 29.00
Meat Lover’s Pizza
16.10/+
Pepperoni, Sausage, Ground Beef and Canadian Bacon | 8”-16.10 • 10” GF - 25.00 • 10" Cauliflower GF - 25.00 • 12”- 25.00 • 14”- 27.00 • 16”- 29.00
Sicilian Pizza
16.10/+
Based with Olive Oil, topped with Mozzarella Cheese, Sausage, and Papa’s Secret Spices | 8”-16.10 • 10” GF - 25.00 • 10" Cauliflower GF - 25.00 • 12”- 25.00 • 14”- 27.00 • 16”- 29.00
Bacon Chicken Ranch
16.10/+
Ranch Dressing, Diced Grilled Chicken, Crispy Bacon Bits, Diced Red Onions and Mozzarella Cheese | 8”-16.10 • 10” GF - 23.00 • 10" Cauliflower GF - 23.00 • 12”- 23.00 • 14”- 24.15 • 16”- 25.30
BBQ Chicken Pizza
16.10/+
Sweet BBQ Sauce, topped with Mozzarella Cheese and tender chunks of Chicken Breast | 8”-16.10 • 10” GF - 25.00 • 10" Cauliflower GF - 25.00 • 12”- 25.00 • 14”- 27.00 • 16”- 29.00
Chicken Parmigiana
16.10/+
Papa’s Famous Pizza Sauce topped with Mozzarella Cheese, Breaded Chicken and sprinkled with Imported Parmesan Cheese | 8”-16.10 • 10” GF - 25.00 • 10" Cauliflower GF - 25.00 • 12”- 25.00 • 14”- 27.00 • 16”- 29.00
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
16.10/+
Papa’s Hand Tossed Dough topped with Frankie’s Special Buffalo Sauce, Diced Grilled Chicken Breast, Red Onions, Mozzarella Cheese and sprinkled with Crushed Red Pepper | 8”-16.10 • 10” GF - 25.00 • 10" Cauliflower GF - 25.00 • 12”- 25.00 • 14”- 27.00 • 16”- 29.00
PB & J
16.10/+
Pepperoni, Bacon, Jalapeno, and a drizzle of Hot Honey | 8”-16.10 • 10” GF - 25.00 • 10" Cauliflower GF - 25.00 • 12”- 25.00 • 14”- 27.00 • 16”- 29.00
Margherita Pizza
16.10/+
Fresh mozzarella, with sliced whole tomatoes, and fresh basil | 8”-16.10 • 10” GF - 25.00 • 10" Cauliflower GF - 25.00 • 12”- 25.00 • 14”- 27.00 • 16”- 29.00
Champagne Pizza
16.10/+
Topped with a champagne sauce, breaded diced chicken, and Italian cheeses | 8”-16.10 • 10” GF - 25.00 • 10" Cauliflower GF - 25.00 • 12”- 25.00 • 14”- 27.00 • 16”- 29.00
New! Buono Pizza
16.10/+
Pepperoni, Onion, Garlic and Cream Cheese | 8”-16.10 • 10” GF - 25.00 • 10" Cauliflower GF - 25.00 • 12”- 25.00 • 14”- 27.00 • 16”- 29.00
Italian Dinners
All Italian Dinners are served with Soup or Salad and our Famous Hot Buttered Garlic Bread. Upgrade to a Caesar Salad for an additional $2.00
Spaghetti
16.00
Served with Papa’s Signature Marinara Sauce and your choice of Meatballs, Meat Sauce, or Italian Sausage Link
Mostaccioli
16.00
Served with Papa’s Signature Marinara Sauce and your choice of Meatballs, Meat Sauce, or Italian Sausage Link
Lasagna Roll Dinner
16.50
Four Lasagna Rolls stuffed with a blend of Ricotta, Mozzarella, Romano, and Parmesan Cheese, baked to perfection in Papa’s Signature Marinara Sauce. With Two Meatballs $19.50
Homemade Meat Lasagna
17.50
A generous portion of our Homemade Lasagna, prepared with Fresh Pasta, Ground Beef, Ricotta, Mozzarella and Parmesan Cheese
Sal’s Italian Trio
18.50
A combination of Two Lasagna Rolls, with Meatballs and a chicken Parmigiana Filet
Cheese Tortellini
16.00
Pasta Rings filled with a blend of cheeses and topped with Papa’s Signature Marinara or Garlic Butter Sauce
Beef Tortellini
16.00
Pasta Rings filled with a blend of Beef and topped with Papa’s Signature Marinara or Garlic Butter Sauce
Stuffed Cheese Ravioli
17.50
Homemade Pasta Pillows filled with choice of Cheese, topped with Papa’s Signature Marinara Sauce
Beef Ravioli
17.50
Homemade Pasta Pillows filled with choice of Beef, topped with Papa’s Signature Marinara Sauce
Veal Parmigiana
21.00
Hand trimmed & sliced tender Veal breaded with Italian Seasonings and Imported Parmesan topped with Mozzarella Cheese and Papa’s Signature Marinara Sauce, served on a bed of Linguini
Chicken Parmigiana
17.25
Breaded Chicken Breast topped with Mozzarella Cheese and Papa’s Signature Marinara Sauce, served on a bed of Linguini
Fettuccine Alfredo
16.50
Freshly cooked Fettuccine Noodles smothered with our Creamy Alfredo Sauce | With Grilled Chicken -$19.00, With Shrimp -$20.00
Pasta Primavera
16.50
MARIA’S FAVORITE! Linguini Pasta served with Fresh Vegetables, Zucchini, Broccoli, Carrots and Red Peppers in Garlic Butter Sauce | With Grilled Chicken -$19.00, With Shrimp - $20.00
Angel Hair Garlic Pasta
15.25
JOJO’S FAVORITE! Tender thin Pasta sautéed with Garlic Butter Sauce | With Grilled Chicken -$17.75, With Shrimp -$18.75
Gnocchi
17.25
A Northern Italian Favorite! Tender Pasta Dumplings served with Papa’s Signature Marinara Sauce and your choice of Meatballs, Meat Sauce or Italian Sausage Link
Spiedini
21.00
A SICILIAN DELICACY! Thin sliced Beef Tenderloin marinated in Olive Oil, hand-rolled & stuffed with Sicilian Bread Crumbs, Topped with sautéed Mushrooms & Onions. Served with a blend of Vegetables | *Choice of Potato or Pasta
Chicken Pasta Florentine
18.00
Chicken Sautéed With Fresh Garlic Butter And Tossed With Fresh Tomatoes, Spinach And Spiral Pasta
Mediterranean Pasta
18.00
Sautéed Spinach, Tomatoes, Onion, Garlic, Feta Cheese, Kalamata Olives, Oregano, Fresh Squeezed Lemon Juice, White Wine and Olive Oil over Linguine | With Chicken - $20.50, With Shrimp - $21.50
Pasta Formaggio
14.00
Fusilli pasta tossed in cheese sauce topped and baked with Italian bread crumbs | With Grilled Chicken -$16.50, With Bacon -$18.00
Seafood Specialties
Seafood specialties include soup or salad and garlic bread. Upgrade to Caesar salad for additional $2.00
Crab Linguini
22.00
Over One-Half Pound of True Snowcrab, Sautéed to Perfection in our Signature Alfredo Sauce, Served over a Bed of Linguini Noodles
Sal’s Seafood Sensation
23.00
A Generous Sampling of Shrimp, Lobster, Scallops and Crabmeat Sautéed to Perfection, Served over a Bed of Fresh Linguini Noodles in Your Choice of One of Our Signature Sauces (Marinara, Alfredo or Garlic Butter)
Shrimp Skewers
19.50
2 Shrimp Scampi Skewers grilled to perfection, served over a bed of Angel Hair Pasta sautéed with Garlic Butter Sauce. Served with a Blend of Italian Vegetables
Crab Fusilli
22.00
Spiral pasta tossed with champagne sauce topped with fresh tomato and spinach and succulent crab meat
Sandwiches
Make it a platter for only $3.00, Includes coleslaw and your choice of crinkle cut fries, beer battered fries +$1, Potato wedges +$1, baked potato, or choice of pasta with marinara, garlic butter, Alfredo sauce +$2, Champagne sauce +$2, Onion rings +$1, sautéed vegetables +$1 | Additional Toppings: Cheese, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Black Olives, Onions 1.00 Each
Sicilian Steak Sandwich
16.00
A generous portion of hand-cut Beef Tenderloin, perfectly seasoned with Italian Spices, breaded and smothered with Red & Green Peppers, Onions, and Mozzarella Cheese
Breaded Chicken Filet Sandwich
12.00
Hand-breaded Chicken Breast fried to a golden brown, topped with Lettuce and Tomato
Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich
10.00
Marinated Chicken Breast grilled to perfection, topped with
Lettuce and Tomato
Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich
12.00
Breaded Chicken Breast topped with Mozzarella and Parmesan Cheese and Papa’s Signature Marinara Sauce
Veal Parmigiana Sandwich
15.00
Hand trimmed & sliced Tender Veal breaded in Italian Seasonings and Imported Cheese, topped with Mozzarella Cheese and Papa’s Signature Marinara Sauce
Italian Beef Sandwich
13.00
TORY'S FAVORITE! Thin sliced marinated beef smothered with mozzarella cheese, onions, and red and green peppers
Pizza Burger
12.00
PAPA’S MOST FAMOUS! Italian sausage patty smothered with mozzarella cheese and topped with Papa’s signature marinara sauce. Additional toppings available: mushrooms, onion, green peppers, black olives, and pepperoni for $1.00 each
Italian Meatball Sandwich
12.00
Homemade Italian meatballs topped with mozzarella cheese and Papa’s signature marinara sauce. Additional toppings $1.00 each
Hamburger
9.00
Quarter Pound Burger topped with Lettuce, Tomato, and Onion
Cheeseburger
10.00
Quarter Pound Burger topped with your choice of Mozzarella or
American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato and Onion
Fish Sandwich
10.00
Premium Alaskan Cod, battered and fried to a golden brown. Topped with Lettuce, Tomato, and Onion. Served with a side of Tartar Sauce
Pocket Pizza (Calzone)
12.00
Mozzarella Cheese, Papa’s Signature Marinara Sauce and One Topping sealed inside a folded Pizza Crust and cooked to perfection. Add toppings for $1 each.
American Dinners
All Dinners include soup or salad, coleslaw, hot buttered bread and your choice of crinkle cut fries, beer battered fries +$1, Potato wedges +$1, baked potato, or choice of pasta with marinara, garlic butter, Alfredo sauce +$2, Champagne sauce +$2, Onion rings +$1, sautéed vegetables +$1 | Upgrade to a Caesar Salad for an additional $2.00
Beer Battered Cod Dinner
15.00
Premium Alaskan Cod battered & cooked to perfection. Served with Rye Bread
Broasted Chicken Dinner
15.00
Fresh marinated Chicken broasted until golden brown
Perch Dinner
18.50
Filets of Lake Perch, breaded and deep-fried to a golden brown. Served with Rye Bread
Shrimp Basket
16.00
12 lb lightly breaded deep fried Shrimp served with Cocktail Sauce
BBQ Pork Ribs
20.00/1/2 Rack
31.00/Full Rack
Baby Back Ribs slow roasted & smothered with our own Sweet BBQ Sauce. SO TENDER THEY FALL OFF THE BONE.
Chicken Tender Dinner
15.00
Tender Strips of Chicken Breast breaded and cooked until golden brown
Sal’s Jumbo Shrimp
19.00
Supersize Gulf Shrimp lightly breaded & deep-fried to golden perfection. Served with Cocktail Sauce and Rye Bread.
Fresh From Our Garden
Salad Dressings: Italian, French, Ranch, Thousand Island, Honey Mustard, Parmesan Peppercorn, Greek, Caesar, Raspberry Vinaigrette, Bleu Cheese
Mediterranean Salad
15.00
A Bed of Fresh Lettuce topped with a Boneless Grilled Chicken Breast, Tomatoes, Onions, Feta Cheese, Greek Olives and Greek Dressing. Served with Garlic Bread.
Grilled Chicken Salad
14.00
A Bed of Fresh Lettuce topped with a Boneless Grilled Chicken Breast, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Black Olives, and Mozzarella Cheese. Served with Garlic Bread.
Side Caesar Salad
6.50
Fresh Romaine, tossed with our house Caesar Dressing,
Grated Parmesan, and Croutons.
Chef Salad
13.00
Fresh Lettuce, Tomatoes, Black Olives, Mozzarella Cheese, Mushrooms, Green Peppers and Pepperoni. Served with Garlic Bread
Caesar Salad
12.00
Fresh Romaine Lettuce with Imported Parmesan Cheese, Croutons tossed in Caesar Dressing. Served with Garlic Bread | With Grilled Chicken $14.00 or Shrimp $15.00
Side Salad
5.00
Greens, Onion, Tomato, Cucumber and choice of dressing.
Sides
Bread Basket
3.50
Baked Potato
2.75
House Salad
3.50
Soups
2.25/Cup
3.25/Bowl
Pepperoncini
1.50
Mixed Vegetables
4.00
Extra Portion of Cod
3.00
Red Sauce
1.25/Small
2.00/Large
Tartar Sauce
1.25/Small
2.00/Large
Coleslaw
1.25/Small
2.00/Large
Barbecue Sauce
1.25
Extra Dressing
1.25
Meatball
2.50
Chicken Breast
3.50
Hand Breaded Veal Filet
5.50
Italian Sausage Patty
3.50
Italian Sausage Link
2.50
Pasta with Papa’s Signature Marinara Sauce
3.25
Pasta with Garlic Butter Sauce
3.25
Alfredo Sauce
2.25/Small
4.50/Large